Breaking Brown

November 16, 2011

readers wanted…

writer

Few things annoy me more than asking an acquaintance if they read the most recent column by a journalist we both enjoy, only to hear them answer “I stopped reading her after…” or whatever.

Listen, if you stopped reading columnist X after she said this or that, then the writer benefits from your absence in the mezzanine of the peanut gallery. The writer may be a hack, but you sir-(or ma’am), are an idiot.

All I’m saying is that any person who decides that -after their 500th Cynthia Tucker, David Ignatius, Maureen Dowd, Jared Ball, James Fallows, or Yvette Carnell article that the writer just “isn’t for them”, solely because said writer made a couple of specious or broadly defined arguments, just isn’t very bright.

Whatever infraction assaulted your delicate sensibility better be damned serious for you to throw out the writer with the bath water. I mean, everyone has an off day. Everyone makes a weak argument. But what does it say about you that you can’t abide a contradiction, an off day, or worse – a writer who disagrees with you. What does it say about you that you made this writer’s column appointment reading until he or she deviated from your inconsistent standard?

Here’s the truth; the writer’s probably a much better purveyor of information than you are an interpreter of it. If the writer were not at least decent, you wouldn’t have been a such a fanboy in the first place. And if you were an emotionally stable person, then it wouldn’t peeve you to no end that the writer didn’t meet your expectations. That he or she didn’t present the argument the way you would have isn’t a grown up reason to ditch her. But either way, good riddance.

0 likes Black Media # ,
Share: / / /

6 thoughts on “readers wanted…

  1. Darryl Cox says:

    God, do I really have to start reading David Brooks and Ross Douthat again? You, on the other hand, I always enjoy reading. All the time.

    1. Yvette says:

      Thanks Darryl! But you know, I would just appreciate it if folks would allow for more than one offense before jumping ship. I totally get it if the writer makes an offensive inference or some other such nonsense, but most often that’s not the case.

  2. Alex Pierre Louis says:

    Damn sis, you went all in on somebody. I feel you though. Once again good stuff.

    1. Yvette says:

      Sometimes you just gotta put it all out there, ya know?. 🙂

  3. Cole Sherard says:

    I gotta bookmark this site it seems extremely helpful very beneficial

  4. I like this post, enjoyed this one thankyou for putting up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Support Independent Black Media

Support Independent Black Media




Make a One Time Donation




Subscribe to our Exclusive Paid Newsletter